Right now the only decentralized exchange for cryptocurrencies is bisq.network. It is based on TOR.

As far as I understand it, Kovri is a better way to obfuscate network analysis.

Is it possible for bisq to switch to kovri? What would be the advantages? Are there drawbacks?


The approach of network traffic obfuscation is quite similar in both projects, however there are some major differences.

TOR is used by a vast majority of users as a proxy service for the clearnet, what we commonly call "internet" but only a small percentage of users are acting as nodes actually relaying traffic for others.

I2P on which Kovri is based has a different approach and is not designed to proxy clearnet traffic but to build a really decentralised network of equal nodes which all act as relays by default.

In general, TOR is more centralised, since comparatively few strong nodes with good connectivity are relaying most of the traffic. This is even more valid for "exit" nodes to the internet, since many relays don't want to act as such for security or legal reasons. An attacker might setup many of these strong nodes to control a major chunk of all relayed traffic and log its activity on the network to determine where it actually comes from and where it goes to.

These aspects disappear for I2P network since there are no "exit" nodes and for any node it is not distinguishable if the current traffic it relays (which is encrypted) is intended for the node it is actually communicating or if it is just another relay. Every single user / node makes the network stronger against attacks aiming to overtake the network and log its traffic.

Summing up probably it would benefit decentralised exchanges to choose I2P over TOR and it would also benefit the I2P network, since TOR (at least in terms of users) is probably more popular. However, when it comes to relaying nodes it probably is not.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.