0

Trying to avoid paying unnecessary fees when sending multiple transactions (to different people) we wanted to implement transaction batching - sending one transaction with multiple receivers (as it works on bitcoin)

We are now getting this error response: A single payment id is allowed per transaction

which as I understand means that more than one of the receiving addresses are "Integrated addresses" that contains "Payment ID" different from each other

  1. Is it common (or how common?) that wallets (mobile, exchanges etc.) generates only Integrated addresses these days?
  2. Is it common that new Payment ID would be generated for each incoming payment?
  3. If yes, is it still feasible to send multiple transactions in one to save on network fees? Or was it only possible when Integrated addresses and Payment IDs were less commonly used before?

Is this comment from github still true?

  • you can't send in one transaction to multiple different integrated addresses
  • you can send in one transaction to 1 integrated address and multiple regular
  • you can't send in one transaction to the same integrated address (at the moment) if you pass the same integrated address to destinations array more than 1 time

Edit: I just learned that not just Standard and Integrated addresses exist but also Subaddresses which seems to be default(?). I also found this note:

Raw address is still useful for: [...] accepting from senders who batch payouts (like mining pools); in this scenario the sender is paying multiple parties using a single transaction; such transaction has multiple outputs; subaddresses do not work in this scenario

So my question still stays, which address type to expect users would use the most and is it worth it trying to implement batching and group transactions per Payment ID and address type if it would be almost always 1 trx per payment ID anyway?

1

How to batch-send multiple transactions

So if you want to batch transactions (though this is a moot point given how low Monero transaction fees are), you must use either standard addresses or subaddresses. You can still use a payment ID, but only one.

1
  • we send to different people and dont't collect payment ID so standard and subaddresses will be OK to batch and we will send to integrated addresses one by one. thanks
    – premek.v
    Feb 26 at 14:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.