2

A few cryptocurrency projects have instant sending of coins, like Dash and Loki's Blink. Currently with Monero there is a 2-20 minute wait time, depending on how you look at it, before the coins are received. Is there a proposal to get Monero to speed up transactions, like instant sending without the transaction wait times?

4

In Monero, like other cryptocurrencies, the transactions themselves are fairly instant - they get instantly broadcast to the network and get placed in the tx pool. Wallets also see these transactions pretty much instantly.

A transaction however is not deemed confirmed until it has been mined into a block. And even then, because there can be small reorgs on the main chain, allowing a sensible depth of blocks mined increases the likelihood of a transaction sticking (i.e. not being naturally caught up in a reorg or a malicious double spend for example).

This is the reason the Monero wallets enforce a 10 block (~20 minutes) confirmation/lock time before deeming a transaction fully complete.

A receiver (merchant) of XMR, can of course choose any confirmation window they like to release goods. Some merchants will take on a small risk by releasing goods on a zero-conf basis (e.g. as soon as they see the tx in the tx pool). In this situation it is an "instant" transaction of goods. The merchant is taking a small risk here by releasing goods before they are sure the tx won't get reversed.

All cryptocurrencies based on a PoW chain have this situation. Of course, others may develop wallets that don't place a sensible lock time on funds, but then they are pushing the risk onto users who may not fully understand the risks / implication of this.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.