2

ok, so I'm running the standard monero client ( simplewallet ).

Twice now I have received incoming transfers from shapeshift.io. The shapeshift interface notified me at the moment the xmr transfer was sent and provides a link to a block explorer to view the tx. So clearly the tx has been broadcast to the network.

Yet nothing appears in my monero wallet for 1-2 minutes.

I tried the balance and the show_transfer commands.

I see that there is an incoming_transfers command, but I did not try it until after the tx already showed up.

I am used to bitcoin and other altcoins get getinfo, getbalance, list_transactions, etc all show incoming transfers as soon as they are broadcast/received.

It's kind of spooky not to see the coins immediately. Also, I think it would be especially annoying during in-person exchanges.

"hey i sent you the coins".

"hmm, I don't see them."

"still don't see them". ( 30 seconds later )

"are you sure you sent to the right address?!!". ( 30 seconds later )

etc.

more than likely there is a way to see them immediately and this is me being a newb, but I wanted to raise the question because I think it is a rough-edge that newbs will bump into a lot, so maybe the devs can address it in the software somehow.

  • Do you have the auto_refresh option set? Most likely shapeshift and block explorer are just polling every second or something, and you are not checking quite as frequently. – jwinterm Aug 16 '16 at 4:40
6

The explorer is likely listing the transasctions that are in the pool (ie, not yet mined). Recent simplewallet will show those with show_tranfers, as "pool".

Bear in mind that a transaction in the pool which hasn't been mined is not yours yet. If all goes well, it'll be yours soon, but you should not trust a pool transaction yet for large amounts if you think the other party might try to scam you.

  • if you think the other party might try to scam you -> what do you mean? Once the transaction is in the pool, it can't be cancelled, right? – assylias Jan 17 '18 at 12:58
  • Another might be mined which renders the first one invalid. – user36303 Jan 17 '18 at 14:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.