How is the number of ring members selected?

Question

How is the number of ring members signing a transaction selected? Is it selected randomly by the sender or is it defined by the Monero wallet?

jtgrassie · Accepted Answer · 2019-01-05 22:17:13Z

4

Ring size is currently fixed to 11 (10 decoys).

It's defined at a protocol level, so no transaction will be accepted by the network from a wallet not sending transactions with ring size 11.

For reference, this was implemented in this commit.

Credit to @dEBRUYNE♦ and @user36303 for spurring me on to finding it in the code!

answered Jan 4 at 3:05

jtgrassie

5,8801528

1

Note that a static ring size of 11 is also enforced on the protocol level currently. Put differently, no other ring size value can be used. – dEBRUYNE♦ Jan 4 at 9:06
1

You sure? I followed the discussions on this and I thought it ended up as a minimum, not fixed, but wallets could still add higher. Briefly looked at the code and also couldn't find it fixed at the protocol level either, only wallet level – jtgrassie Jan 4 at 14:46
Yes. I, alas, cannot find the relevant pull request either currently. – dEBRUYNE♦ Jan 4 at 16:56
Theres a couple for the wallets and min set globally here. So not fixed. – jtgrassie Jan 5 at 0:29
It is fixed (modulo special cases with unmixable inputs). See check_tx_inputs. – user36303 Jan 5 at 0:40

| show 1 more comment

1 Answer 1